| 2009 | |
|
Steven Gray (MVP) |
Gonzaga |
| Matt Bouldin (MVP) | Gonzaga |
|
Yancy Gates |
Cincinnati |
| Trevon Hughes | Wisconsin |
| Nic Wise | Arizona |
| Deonta Vaughn | Cincinnati |
| 2008 | |
| Ty Lawson | North Carolina |
| Luke Harangody | Notre Dame |
| Danny Green | North Carolina |
| Kyle McAlarney | Notre Dame |
| Tyler Hansbrough | North Carolina |
| 2007 | |
| Kyle Singler | Duke |
| DeMarcus Nelson | Duke |
| Dominic James | Marquette |
| Jerel McNeal | Marquette |
| Calvin Brock | Illinois |
| 2006 | |
| Darren Collison | UCLA |
| Lewis Clinch | Georgia Tech |
| Chris Douglas-Roberts | Memphis |
| Arron Afflalo | UCLA |
| Carl Landry | Purdue |
| 2005 | |
| Adam Morrison | Gonzaga |
| J.P. Batista | Gonzaga |
| Hilton Armstrong | Connecticut |
| Denham Brown | Connecticut |
| Maurice Ager | Michigan State |
| 2004 | |
| Raymond Felton | North Carolina |
| Jeff Horner | Iowa |
| Rashad McCants | North Carolina |
| Taquan Dean | Louisville |
| Brad Buckman | Texas |
| 2003 | |
| Sean Finn | Dayton |
| Michael Kuebler | Hawaii |
| Ramond Marshall | Dayton |
| Aerick Sanders | San Diego State |
| Keith Waleskowski | Dayton |
| 2002 | |
| Keith Bogans | Kentucky |
| Travis Watson | Virginia |
| Ronny Turiaf | Gonzaga |
| Jeff Newton | Indiana |
| Bracey Wright | Indiana |
| 2001 | |
| Mike Dunleavy | Duke |
| Jay Williams | Duke |
| Patrick Jackson | Ball State |
| Jason Kapono | UCLA |
| Drew Gooden | Kansas |
| 2000 | |
| Jason Gardner | Arizona |
| Marcus Griffin | Illinois |
| Kaspars Kambala | UNLV |
| Frank Williams | Illinois |
| Michael Wright | Arizona |